PickFaire

For hosts and for entrants

How to prove a giveaway was not rigged

The short answer: fix the list of entries before the randomness exists, publish both, and let anyone repeat the draw. A video of a spinning wheel cannot do that. A locked list, a public beacon round and a ledger of every draw can.

Run a provable draw Verify a draw

  1. 1

    Publish the rules before the draw

    Who can enter, the entry period with time zone, what counts as an entry, how many winners and backups, how winners are contacted. Use the same rules in the draw.

  2. 2

    Lock the entry list and publish its fingerprint

    Every public comment and reply is read, the rules are applied, and the eligible list is frozen with a SHA-256 hash and the number of the drand round that will decide, published at least 20 seconds later.

  3. 3

    Let the beacon pick, then share one link

    When the round is published the winners are computed from it. Share the results page: it carries the list, the hash, the round, the seed and a button that re-runs the draw.

Why the usual proofs do not prove much

What does prove something is a draw whose inputs were public before the result existed, and whose result anyone can compute again.

For hosts: what to share

Brands and agencies who need this on file: an audit trail for every giveaway.

For entrants: how to check a result

  1. Ask the host for the results link. A host running a fair draw has one.
  2. On the results page, type your username: you see whether your comments were read, whether each counted, the reason if not, and your place in the locked list.
  3. Check the lock time is before the beacon round time, and that comments read is close to the count Instagram shows (Instagram hides some comments from everyone, so a small gap is normal).
  4. Open the post ledger: every draw on the post is there, redraws and withdrawn locks included.
  5. Press the button that re-runs the draw in your browser, or use the reference code yourself.

If the giveaway was not run on this site, none of this exists for it, and the most you can do is ask the host how the winner was chosen and with which list.

What this cannot prove

Questions

Can I prove my giveaway was fair after I already picked the winner somewhere else?

Not after the fact. Proof comes from publishing the entry list before the randomness exists. For the next giveaway, lock the list here before you draw.

Can the host redraw until a friend wins?

Every redraw uses a new, later beacon round and is labelled on the results page with the earlier winners. Every draw ever locked on the post is on its public ledger, and the host cannot delete those rows.

Can I check that I was in the draw?

Yes. On the results page, type your Instagram username: you see whether your comments were read, whether each counted (and why not), and your place in the locked list.

Where does the randomness come from?

From drand, the public randomness beacon run by the League of Entropy. Its "quicknet" chain publishes a new random value every 3 seconds, signed by a threshold of independent operators. PickFaire uses the first round published at least 20 seconds after your entry list is locked.

Is a livestream of the draw enough?

It is better than nothing, but it still shows only the draw on camera, not the list it ran on or whether there were earlier draws. A published list hash, a beacon round and a post ledger can be checked later by anyone.

Is PickFaire free?

Free for posts with up to 300 comments: 3 winners and 3 backups, every comment read, the full proof. Bigger posts take a one-time Draw Pass: $6.99 up to 10,000, $12.99 up to 50,000, $19.99 up to 200,000 comments.