PickFaire

The pillar page

A provably fair giveaway picker

"Random" is easy to claim. These are the three things a draw on this site lets anyone check, and the things no picker can honestly promise.

Nobody could choose the seed

The entry list is locked and published first. The randomness comes from a drand round published at least 20 seconds later by the League of Entropy, a network of independent organisations. Neither the host nor PickFaire can know or influence that round's value in advance.

The list drawn from is the list that was committed

The results page shows the SHA-256 hash of the locked entry list from the moment of the lock. Anyone can download the list, hash it and re-run the shuffle in a browser, in Python or by hand.

Every draw on the post is listed

Each post has a public ledger of every draw locked on it on PickFaire: redraws, withdrawn locks and deleted draws included. A host cannot quietly draw again until a friend wins.

1. The beacon draw: the seed did not exist when the list was locked

Most pickers generate a random number on their own server. Even when they publish it afterwards, you have to trust that they did not try several numbers, or edit the list, until they liked the winner.

On PickFaire, pressing Lock entries and draw freezes the eligible entries in order and publishes a commitment at once: the draw code, the SHA-256 hash of the list, the number of entries, the rules, the lock time and the drand round number R, the first round published at least 20 seconds after the lock. The winners do not exist yet. When round R is published, the seed is computed from its randomness and the shuffle runs.

What it proves: nobody could pick or predict the seed for this list, because the list was public before the randomness existed. What it does not prove: anything about who commented. A host can still exclude accounts by rule; the rules are published with the commitment, so entrants can see them.

2. The committed list is the list that was drawn

The locked list is published as a plain text file of entry ids and usernames. Its SHA-256 hash is on the results page from the moment of the lock. After the draw anyone can download the file, check the hash, fetch the beacon round from a drand relay and re-run the shuffle: the verify page shows how, with reference code in JavaScript and Python, and every results page has a button that does it in the browser.

Every entrant can also type their username on the results page and see whether their comments were read, whether each counted, the reason if not, and their place in the list. Only exact usernames work: the check does not list or suggest anyone else.

3. Every draw on the post is listed

The usual way to rig a "random" giveaway is to redraw quietly until the right person wins. Each post here has a public ledger: every draw ever locked on it on this site, newest first, with lock time, entry count, list hash, beacon round, winners and redraw labels. A lock can only be withdrawn before its round is published, and the withdrawal is listed too. If a host deletes a draw, a row stays with its code, times, hash and round, without usernames.

What no picker can honestly promise

Is a screen recording proof?

A recording shows that a button was pressed once on camera. It cannot show how many times the draw was run before, or whether the list was edited. A locked list with a published hash, a public beacon round and a post ledger can be checked by anyone, later, without trusting the person who recorded it.

Questions

Where does the randomness come from?

From drand, the public randomness beacon run by the League of Entropy. Its "quicknet" chain publishes a new random value every 3 seconds, signed by a threshold of independent operators. PickFaire uses the first round published at least 20 seconds after your entry list is locked.

Can the host redraw until a friend wins?

Every redraw uses a new, later beacon round and is labelled on the results page with the earlier winners. Every draw ever locked on the post is on its public ledger, and the host cannot delete those rows.

Can I check that I was in the draw?

Yes. On the results page, type your Instagram username: you see whether your comments were read, whether each counted (and why not), and your place in the locked list.

Does it read every comment?

Every draw, free or paid, reads every public comment and reply on the post. The draw page and the results page show the number read next to the number Instagram reports.