Giveaway fairness: the hard questions
The objections entrants actually raise, answered without overselling.
Questions
"The host could just redraw until a friend wins."
Not quietly. Every draw locked on a post is on its public ledger, newest first, with its round and winners. Redraws are labelled on the results page with the earlier winners. A withdrawn lock is listed too, and a lock can only be withdrawn before its beacon round exists, so a host cannot see the result and then cancel it.
"The tool could cheat."
The tool does not choose the randomness. The seed is computed from a drand round published after the list was locked and made public, by a formula anyone can recompute. If we changed the list, its hash would not match the one published at the lock. If we changed the seed or the shuffle, the browser verifier and the reference code would show a mismatch.
"What if my comment was missed?"
Type your username on the results page. It shows whether your comments were read and whether each counted. Instagram hides some comments from everyone (spam filter, restricted accounts, hidden words), and no tool can read those; the page shows comments read next to Instagram's own count so a big gap is visible.
"What about fake accounts and bots?"
A fair draw gives every eligible entry the same chance, including entries from accounts that look fake. Hosts can exclude accounts by rule before the lock, and the exclusions are published with the commitment. After the draw, a host may disqualify a winner under their own published rules and move to the backups, which were fixed by the same draw.
"Is a screen recording proof?"
It proves one press of a button on camera. It does not show earlier runs, or whether the list was edited. A published list hash, a public beacon round and the post ledger can be checked by anyone afterwards.
"Could the host add their friends to the list?"
Host-added bonus entries (for example story shares) are allowed, are counted separately on the results page and are inside the locked list and its hash. They must be added before the lock.
"Could the host pick a moment when the beacon favours a friend?"
No. The host locks first; the round is fixed at the lock as the first one at least 20 seconds later, and its value cannot be known before it is published.
"Do follow checks cover everyone?"
No. A follow check runs on the people drawn, in order, and skips anyone who provably does not follow; skipped names are listed. Private accounts cannot be checked and are never rejected for that.
"Does this prove likes or story shares?"
No. Instagram does not make likes and story shares checkable in public. Only comments, and host-added entries that are disclosed as such.